Douglas Smith (left) and Matthew Shear as Jewish fraternal twins on The Alienist.
Douglas Smith (left) and Matthew Shear as Jewish fraternal twins on The Alienist.

Matthew Shear, The Alienist And Judaism

The 10-part miniseries The Alienist is TNT’s adaptation of Caleb Carr’s 1994 novel set in 1896 amidst the vast wealth, extreme poverty and technological innovation of New York City during the Gilded Age. A criminal psychologist, a newspaper illustrator and a police department secretary investigate the grisly serial murders of young boys.

Joining them are 20-something Jewish fraternal twins Lucius (Matthew Shear) and Marcus Isaacson (Douglas Smith), criminal science and forensics experts serving as detective sergeants under the new police commissioner, Teddy Roosevelt, later to become the 26th president of the United States.

“I felt very connected to the story of Jewish brothers making their way in New York City,” said Shear, who is Jewish and a New York native. His mother, a first-generation American, “had to negotiate what it means to be Jewish and the daughter of immigrant parents who were fleeing the Holocaust,” he said. “She became a scientist, which was not expected of her.”

“I don’t feel compelled to only play Jewish characters, but there’s something very rewarding about it.”

— Matthew Shear

Shear said the miniseries follows the narrative of the book but also expands on some of the storylines, including scenes involving the Isaacsons. The show brings viewers into their home, where they live with their mother and light candles on Shabbat.

Shear described Lucius as a mama’s boy who speaks Yiddish and is more traditional and religious than the more assimilated, modern Marcus. When Marcus begins a sexual relationship with a young Jewish woman, conflict arises because Lucius thinks he should marry her, while Marcus has more progressive views.

“Marcus is trying to find his own Jewish identity as an American,” Shear said.

“There’s a scene toward the end of the season where we interrogate an Irish police officer suspected of a crime,” Shear said. “As we try to get information from him, he is defiant and throws a lot of hateful language at us and says we’re unfit to do police work because we’re Jewish.”As Jews in a predominantly gentile police force that Roosevelt is trying to modernize and rid of corruption, the Isaacsons are sometimes the butt of jokes and anti-Semitic comments from fellow officers.

Matthew Shear

Matthew Shear

As the brothers help to solve crimes, “they bicker, but work in tandem,” Shear said. “They have a dynamic that you don’t see with the other characters.”

The actor emphasized that the close relationship the brothers have with each other and their mother stands in contrast to the troubled and lonely souls that populate much of The Alienist.

As research for his role, Shear relished delving into forensics history, preparing for scenes by studying how then-new methods like fingerprinting and crime scene photography were used in 1896. He and Smith “were trained in the use of an original box camera from the period,” he said.

Actor Matthew Shear’s Jewish roots help him relate to his role in The Alienist.

“The premise of the show fascinated me because I’m pretty interested in psychology and the mystery of the mind,” Shear said.

During the six-month shoot in Budapest, Hungary, Shear made time to visit Jewish heritage sites, including the Grand Dohany Street Synagogue and the adjacent Tree of Life Holocaust Memorial several times. When his parents came to visit, his Yiddish tutor, also a tour guide and an amateur cantor, took them through the Old Jewish Quarter. “I really enjoyed living in Budapest, though it has a very dark history for Jews,” he said.

Raised in Manhattan and in Larchmont, N.Y., Shear, 33, grew up in a Reform Jewish home, attended Hebrew school, celebrated Jewish holidays and became a bar mitzvah.

“My dad’s grandparents emigrated from Russia in the 1890s and my mom’s parents were able to flee Belgium during World War II. They got Bolivian visas and went to Cuba,” he said, noting that he feels very connected to his Jewish identity and culture. He now belongs to a Reform synagogue on New York ‘s Upper West Side and celebrates the major holidays with his family.

Douglas Smith (left) and Matthew Shear as Jewish fraternal twins on The Alienist.

Douglas Smith (left) and Matthew Shear as Jewish fraternal twins on The Alienist.

Exposed to movies and theater as a child, Shear followed his older brother into school plays and became hooked. Taking Woodstock (2009) was his first film, and he’s been in three movies directed by Noah Baumbach: While We’re Young, Mistress America and The Meyerowitz Stories (New and Selected).

Lucius Isaacson is his third Jewish character in a row, after roles in Meyerowitz and the forthcoming The Boy Downstairs, in which he plays the title role of Ben, whose ex-girlfriend is played by Zosia Mamet. “I don’t feel compelled to only play Jewish characters, but there’s something very rewarding about it,” he said, adding that he’s not concerned about typecasting.

“I’ve played non-Jewish characters. I played an Italian-American in Mistress America, my first substantial break,” he said. “I hope to play a range of characters. [And] ‘Jewish’ is not a restrictive category. There are so many kinds of Jewish people. If I end up playing more Jewish characters, I’d be happy to.”

Now, Shear said, he is ready for his next adventure, wherever it takes him: “I’m in a nice place where I’m open to trying something new.”


The Alienist premiered Jan. 22 across TNT platforms and can be viewed on On-Demand.

Gerri Miller Jewish Journal of Greater L.A.


Stay up-to-date with the Detroit Jewish News! Subscribe to our Newsletter.


Support the Detroit Jewish News Foundation

Support the educational mission of the independent, nonprofit Detroit Jewish News Foundation.

%d bloggers like this: