Editor’s Note: Last week, the JN ran a story “Standing With Israel” (page 17, May…
Opinion Counterpoint: Natalie Portman’s Act Of ‘Love’ (And Darkness)
Above: Portman and Peres
Editor’s Note: Oscar-winning actress Natalie Portman backed out of a major award ceremony meant to honor her in Jerusalem, with her representatives citing her distress over “recent events” in Israel. She later issued a statement saying that her objection was to the scheduled presence of the Israeli prime minister at the ceremony.
We believe this topic is relevant to our readers and the interests of our community; however, the views and opinions expressed on this page do not necessarily reflect the views of the Detroit Jewish News.
When you truly love a person or a country, you are extremely grateful for those people who help and protect that person; you appreciate the brave young soldiers who protect the country you love.
But for Natalie Portman — like others on the extreme, frightened left — “loving” and “caring for” Israel means vilifying and demonizing those who risk their own lives and leaders who work and worry day and night protecting the Israeli people.
It’s especially painful to see Portman-type attacks on Israel when Israel is fighting against Nazi-like Hamas, which calls for the murder of every Jew and the Jewish state’s destruction. And, meanwhile, Palestinian Arab leaders continue to promote murder and hatred against Jews and Israel in their speeches, schools, media and mosques, and they continue their heinous practice of paying Arabs to murder Jews.
Natalie Portman and the rest of the frightened left almost never condemn Israel’s monstrous Arab/Islamist enemies, who shoot and stab and ram cars into Israeli citizens and visitors every day.
The Portman version of “loving” Israel means saying on the one hand, “I treasure my Israeli friends and family, Israeli food, books, art, cinema and dance”— and then, in the very same statement (as well as in her original statement) viciously insulting and demonizing Israel, Israel’s democratically elected prime minister and Israel’s Defense Forces with obscene, false accusations.
Doesn’t she realize that without Israel defending its border against Hamas assaults, and without Israel defending its people from the deadly Palestinian Arab attacks on Jews incited by and paid for by Palestinian Authority dictator Abbas, there would be no “Israeli friends, Israeli food, books, art, cinema and dance”? Portman’s obtuseness is mind-boggling.
Portman’s version of “love” and “caring for Israel” also means a total lack of appreciation for — and indeed, propagandizing against — Israel’s brave, extraordinarily ethical 18-year-olds who form the thin line preventing Molotov cocktail-throwing, armed-to-the-teeth, Nazi-like Hamas mobs from breaching Israel’s border to carry out their blood-curdling screams of “Death to the Jews.”
Portman’s type of “love” and “caring for Israel” means mindlessly spouting the lies emanating from Hamas and the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement, which seek to isolate and destroy the Jewish state. When Portman blasted Israel and defaulted on coming to receive the Genesis Prize, Israel’s Culture Minister Miri Regev aptly noted that Portman “fell into the hands” of the BDS campaign. Indeed, the BDS movement is trumpeting her statements and cancellation of her trip to Israel on the front pages of the BDS movements’ multiple internet sites.
She has also turned around the meaning of “conscience” and taking a brave stand upside down. In today’s world — where anti-Semitism is rife, and especially in Portman’s far-left-wing Hollywood milieu — real bravery means standing up for Israel, the IDF and the Jewish people against relentless anti-Israel propaganda.
Real bravery means condemning the real perpetrators of atrocities: Hamas, whose deeds and charter call for the murder of every Jew, and the P.A., which brags about murdering more Jews than Hamas has, and whose president praises and rewards those who spill Jewish blood.
But Portman pats herself on the back for “taking a stand” against the Jewish state. Incredibly, she even claims that she is furthering “Jewish values.” Meanwhile, she is silent when it comes to the real atrocities perpetrated by Hamas and the P.A.
In short, Portman’s “stands” are pure cowardice.
Portman’s pathetic and shameful diatribe against Israel may, in part, be fueled by a desire to shore up her status in the extremist Israel-hating entertainment world. But is that really worth disgracing herself? David Ben-Gurion and Golda Meir would have been horrified by her ugly, mindless words. Comments on various articles reveal that the vast, overwhelming majority of Jews and other decent folks today are appalled by Portman’s statements and cancellation of her visit to Israel. Hamas and Fatah leaders and neo-Nazis are cheering, heartened and encouraged.
Indeed, Portman’s actions are why clear-thinking Christians often ask us: “What is wrong with those extreme left-wing Jews? Don’t they understand that they’re siding with the people who want to kill them?”
Judaism teaches that the prayer, “You shall love the Lord thy God with all your heart, with all your soul and with all your might,” exemplifies how to truly love. Truly loving Israel and the Jewish people means standing up — with all our might — for the safety of the Jewish state. It means standing up for Israel’s moral young men on the front lines, who are protecting our people from being overrun and slaughtered by Nazi-like Hamas barbarians. Portman’s disgraceful statements and reneging on her trip to Israel show contempt for everything she claims to care about.
Shame on you, Natalie Portman!
Morton A. Klein is the national president of the Zionist Organization of America (ZOA). Liz Berney is ZOA’s director of special projects.